2009 Sharing Lungs Music Draft (Discussion)

[lostpilot]

seriously, Theis, the fact that we're 3 in one poll is insanely unfair.
looking from the perspective of voters and their likes it is impossible to win if you don't have a user friendly list. what I mean is - if, say, I was in a match with one other person, there's a 50/50 chance I win, and now there's only 33 % chance. = not equal rights for all the players. you should have made it in a more democratic way.


plus, seriously - we've been choosing bands for a month and now in a week all three rounds roll and somebody wins?

I am displeased


yes I am too much into this

[tarkil]

You're all right it sucks balls the way it's done...
Thank God I didn't bother to participate in the first place, I would have been so pissed right now !

I thought that there would at least be rounds between each band, and, the winner band stays, the loser one gets eliminated, and we keep the last person with some bands left at the end to be the winner... Or something similar...

But this way is bleh.....

[Livewire]

i thought it was going to be more like the march madness bracket

[defskull]

Yeah someone could have easily had a bye.  I'd be okay with that.  But whatever I'm probably not voting for anyone.  Picking bands was a fun process.

[defskull]

Ehh I changed my mind, I will be voting. 

[theis]

wow you people bitch a lot.
this is the way it's done. don't like it? too fucking bad.

i was trying to do something different, just for fun.

plus, seriously - we've been choosing bands for a month and now in a week all three rounds roll and somebody wins?

what else did you think was going to happen? jeez, it's a silly draft. did you wanted it to last for several months from now on or what?

[Crazylegs]

looking from the perspective of voters and their likes it is impossible to win if you don't have a user friendly list.

If i'm not mistaken, the whole point is to pick a list of bands you think will be voted on.

[lostpilot]

well then I guess I got it all wrong

[Crazylegs]

if you thought the point was something else, i guess you did. Not saying your list was bad though.

[bright lights, big city]

i thought it was going to be more like the march madness bracket

ooh i like that idea


but still, this was fun, a great idea. there are always flaws when something is done for the first time. we should do it again eventually, but maybe modify some aspects just to try them out.

[defTHE1s]

I thought that there would at least be rounds between each band, and, the winner band stays, the loser one gets eliminated, and we keep the last person with some bands left at the end to be the winner... Or something similar...

that's a good idea IMHO...

[oldgentlovecraft]

Hell, I had fun so we should just wrap this one up and do it again with different rules.  I knew I'd get raped seeing as my tastes, although varied, are nothing like the rest of yours lol.  My ass was sore when I made my first pick!  It's cool to finally see everything matched up though and I'd definitely go again.

[theis]

yeah people are welcome to come with suggestions regarding the rules. this was my first time trying this so yea, not everything can be perfect.
glad some still had fun

[An bád dubh]

Yeah, this was fun. Made the rainy spring that much nicer for 3 weeks 

[oldgentlovecraft]

yeah people are welcome to come with suggestions regarding the rules. this was my first time trying this so yea, not everything can be perfect.
glad some still had fun

You did good and kept us entertained.  Maybe we could tweak a few things, but I think it was an excellent idea.  We should have drafts for all sorts of shit, like video games and movies.

[theis]

definitely! i'd love a movie draft.

[Jacob]

it was fun picking bands. dunno about doing it again tho, maybe just let a new bunch of people do it? we're just gonna pick pretty much the same bands next time. and if we don't get to pick any of the bands we picked this time, next time it'll only be obscure bands no one has heard of... actually, that sounds kinda interesting.

[theis]

Round 2 has kicked in. Head over to the games zone and vote

[Scarf_Bitch]

BEER

[bright lights, big city]

well, i'm officially fucked now