Sharing Lungs - Deftones Online Community

New song Melanie!

Started by jujuslim, Sep 19, 2008, 11:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

deafnotes


wither-I

Quote from: mikau on Sep 22, 2008, 04:23 AM
that riff sounds too much like rats, I like the chorus tho

"coming into the nearness of distance"

neutron liar

so much SNW hate, damn.

I don't mind a SNW pt 2 for Eros at all.

This song does sound like filler though.  Kinda forced you know?

Let me point out [for reference in opinion] that I hate RatsRatsRats because it jumped on the metalcore bandwagon. 

glassdomino

I love Rats and I love this song.

nyquil addict

I don't mind at all if this sounds like Rats!, "When Girls Telephone Boys" was extremely similar to "Elite" yet WGTB is far superior and one of deftones greatest songs.

wither-I

i think the song is good. catchy and short.

i remembered when they released FM it was better live than on that disc.

hopefully chino is just the one big paradox he portrays and when he says, "this is our BEST album yet"! -(and then turns out its just iiiiiight....)

so im thinking in dispose, -chino said in that interview on the other thread, when asked the question, "do you think this will be the best deftones record yet?" , and then he replied, "i dunno... maybe..... i havent really sat back and gathered it all in full"(or whtever he said exactly), -my prediction is that the album will be the best, and since melanie isnt "that" great live, that it will be fucking awesome on the album version unlike the miscarriage of FM and it's lesser formed twin Rats...rats....rats......

so in adding this, i say the album will prob reside along white pony better than SNW when speaking of a "dynamic/diverse" and "experimental" album.

i still have faith this album will top snw and be more fluid and conceptually consistent.

"coming into the nearness of distance"

jesusinabowlofdirt

the song is totally awesome, full of energy and the adrenaline pumps through my body,man i get all sweaty from listening to it.
at this version http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iskGOFgbfbQ i think u can hear franks effects rather good, 1:09 --->

pony_01

Around The Fur = Adrenaline part 2 with more melodic songs
Deftones (ST) = White Pony wannabe (Experimental side of White Pony)
Eros = definitely SNW part 2 (Melanie says it all)

jesusinabowlofdirt

just to be clear, snw wasnt a very hard record. when i think of snw i think more of the shitty songs like cherry waves, mein,beware,xerces etc, soft melodic stuff written by chino. this new song isnt like most of the songs on snw just maybe 2 songs so i think its wrong to call it typical snw-stuff

Penicks

Quote from: pony_01 on Sep 22, 2008, 05:42 PM
Deftones (ST) = White Pony wannabe (Experimental side of White Pony)

Bull fucking shit.

emehlen

Quote from: pony_01 on Sep 22, 2008, 05:42 PM
Around The Fur = Adrenaline part 2 with more melodic songs
Deftones (ST) = White Pony wannabe (Experimental side of White Pony)
Eros = definitely SNW part 2 (Melanie says it all)

Did you even listen to those first two albums?

Quote from: Penicks on Sep 22, 2008, 07:06 PM
Quote from: pony_01 on Sep 22, 2008, 05:42 PM
Deftones (ST) = White Pony wannabe (Experimental side of White Pony)

Bull fucking shit.

seriously

Inkblades

The experimental side of White Pony was...

WHITE PONY!!!!


Corleone


Penicks

so does ur mum m8

on my cawk m8

Numina

Quote from: pony_01 on Sep 22, 2008, 05:42 PMEros = definitely SNW part 2 (Melanie says it all)

How can you actually say that a single song represents an entire album that you've never heard?

Hidalgo

Quote from: Numina on Sep 22, 2008, 08:27 PM
Quote from: pony_01 on Sep 22, 2008, 05:42 PMEros = definitely SNW part 2 (Melanie says it all)

How can you actually say that a single song represents an entire album that you've never heard?
makes no sense

deafnotes

this song kinda have the same atmosphere with hexagram/ratsrats

Noia

well i am fucking sure that this song in studio will kick your asses :)

frank's job is great on this one. anyway its great on everyone i know but i really liked melanie i dont care if the riff sounds like rats3x its still a great song. :)

m1nusblindfoLd

#98
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iskGOFgbfbQ

CAN'T....STAND....what occurs at 00:17 and 1:08 arrrghhhhh stoppp what is that? Doing that on SNW/at every show last year was enough.

Otherwise..the song has grown on me a little since I last dissed it in this thread lol. Certainly no classic Tones material and the offbeat vocal parts of the chorus are a little ehh but I like the progressively higher and higher part after the chorus...kinda cool. Definitely does have the feel of Rats and Rapture tho which never held my interest for too long. I want to give this album a chance though before being disappointed.

Nailec

i want the album to have 5 songs that are between 7 and 12 minutes long.